• 18±â ºÏŬ·´

    • ¹æÀå : ¹Ì¸£³ª·¡
    • ´ë»ó : ÁßÇлý
    • µµ¼­¼öÁØ : °íÀü & °úÇÐ

    °íÀü°ú °úÇÐÀ» ÇÔ²² (ÁßÇлýÀÌ ¿î¿µÇÏ´Â ºÏŬ·´ÀÔ´Ï´Ù)

  
[18]The Three Musketeers 4Â÷ ¹Ì¼Ç

±Û¾´ÀÌ ¹Ì¸£³ª·¡

µî·ÏÀÏ 2013-03-18 16:38

Á¶È¸¼ö 1,301

http://www.suksuk.co.kr/momboard/CAX_090/4302

Ä«Ä«¿ÀÅå Ä«Ä«¿À½ºÅ丮 ºí·Î±× ³×À̹ö¹êµå ÆäÀ̽ººÏ Æ®À§ÅÍ
¾¦¾¦´åÄÄ - ÆÄÀÏ ´Ù¿î·Îµå

ÆÄÀÏÀ» ´Ù¿î·Îµå ÇÕ´Ï´Ù.

´ñ±Û ³²±â±â

 

1. Sometimes in life, one person uses another person to get what they want. D' Artagnan did this to Kitty. Debate wthether it is evil to ask such favors from someone who loves you.

 

2. Why do people whisper? What did you say on such occasions?

 

 

To be answered by  3/31 after reading ch35~ch44(431p) of the three musketeers.


¸¶ÀÌ ÆäÀÌÁö > ½ºÅ©·¦ºÏ¿¡¼­ È®ÀÎÇÏ½Ç ¼ö ÀÖ½À´Ï´Ù. ¼ÒÁßÇÑ ±Û¿¡ °¨»ç ´ñ±Û ³²°ÜÁÖ¼¼¿ä.

        
·Î±×ÀÎ ÈÄ µ¡±ÛÀ» ³²°ÜÁÖ¼¼¿ä
annie0717 2013-03-31 19:51 

1. If two people truly love one another, I believe it is justifiable to ask each other favors, though not too excessively. On the other hand, if a person is giving fake love to the other person, while the other really loves him or her, I do not think this is morally right. Manipulating, forcing, and faking affection the other just to get information for his or her own good is obviously the wrong thing to do. I guess the affair between d'Artagnan and Kitty comes down to the matter of true love.

   However, I do think there are exceptions. In d'Artagnan's case, the events that happened between him and Milady were very serious and had his reputation at stake; in some cases, even his life. If it hadn't been for Kitty, d'Artagnan would have never gathered the information he desperately needed from Milady, and even if he did, would have found it hard to escape from the mansion when Milady found out the truth about his little jest.

   Therefore, even though I believe the affairs between d'Artagnan and Kitty would have been unjustifiable without true love, I think it was necessary, considering d'Artagnan's current circumstances.

2. People whisper when they say things which they do not wish to expose to certain people. It usually happens when they dislike a person, when they feel uncomfortable saying it around a certain person, and when they want to communicate secrets between them whether they like the certain person or not. When people whisper to me, I present my answer by shaking my head, whisper back to tell them to be quiet, or just pretend I did not hear the person and ignore him or her.

ºû³ª´ÂÁö 2013-03-31 17:13 

1. I think it is evil. Asking such favors and using another person is not something a person that loves the other would do. In most of the situations like this, I do not think D'Artagnan loves Kitty. He is pretending to love Kitty and abusing her love.

2. There are not much situations that people whisper about good things. They say bad things about someone. They choose whispering because they do not want others to know that the whisperer told bad things about somebody. I normally say, "Maybe.". I sometimes agree, sometimes disagree, or pretend not to have heard.

directioner 2013-03-30 23:38 

1. Yes, I think that it is evil to ask such favors from someone who loves you, because the person will maybe think that you didn't love him or her back and will be very disappointed and sad. If a person uses another person to get what they want, than that kind of person will treat people just as a tool, and people haves feelings, you know, so I think that this act is evil.

2. Well, people usually whisper to each other when they have to talk about something very personal or about the bad things or secrets about other people. When some people whispers something to me, I says things like "That will be probably just a rumor.","I don't care. And why would people do something like that?" or just ignores him or her.

Erin37 2013-03-24 16:58 

1. Of course it isn't good to use of manipulate people who cares for you. The one being used would feel betrayed, hurt, and angry, too. On plain occasions, it will be evil to use people that loves you. But if it is for the good of many people, and if its is really necessary, you would have to do it even if it is evil. Then, you should explain the reason you behaved that way later on.

2. We whisper to each other when we have something to talk about, something that you don't want everyone to know. Something private. At school we whisper about things that happened at school, something that was very shocking and unbelievable. We don't want the people who was envolved in the action. So we whisper. But such things aren't very reliable. It is mostly rumors that fly around. You shouldn't believe the whispering croud.


¹øÈ£ Á¦¸ñ ±Û¾´ÀÌ µî·ÏÀÏ Á¶È¸

   Answers

¹Ì¸£³ª·¡.. 2013/04/01 1,241
3258

 The Three Musketeers 4Â÷ ¹Ì¼Ç

[4]
¹Ì¸£³ª·¡.. 2013/03/18 1,301

   Answer

¹Ì¸£³ª·¡.. 2013/04/10 1,117
3217

 Waves, Sound, and Light 6Â÷ ¹Ì¼Ç

[5]
¹Ì¸£³ª·¡.. 2013/03/07 1,227

   Answers

¹Ì¸£³ª·¡.. 2013/03/18 1,071
3204

 The Three Musketeers 3Â÷ ¹Ì¼Ç

[4]
¹Ì¸£³ª·¡.. 2013/03/04 1,347
3158

 Waves, Sound and Light 5Â÷ ¹Ì¼Ç

[5]
¹Ì¸£³ª·¡.. 2013/02/18 1,223

   Answers

¹Ì¸£³ª·¡.. 2013/03/03 1,151
3157

 The Three Musketeers 2Â÷ ¹Ì¼Ç

[5]
¹Ì¸£³ª·¡.. 2013/02/18 1,227

   Answers

¹Ì¸£³ª·¡.. 2013/03/03 979
3125

 The Three Musketeers 1Â÷ ¹Ì¼Ç

[5]
¹Ì¸£³ª·¡.. 2013/02/05 1,305
3124

 Waves, Sound, and Light 4Â÷ ¹Ì¼Ç

[5]
¹Ì¸£³ª·¡.. 2013/02/05 1,245

   Answers

¹Ì¸£³ª·¡.. 2013/02/22 1,010
3104

 [Notice] Pride and Prejudice Book Report

[5]
¹Ì¸£³ª·¡.. 2013/01/29 1,952
3087

 Pride and Prejudice 3Â÷ ¹Ì¼Ç

[6]
¹Ì¸£³ª·¡.. 2013/01/21 1,360
3085

 Waves, Sound, and Light 3Â÷ ¹Ì¼Ç

[5]
¹Ì¸£³ª·¡.. 2013/01/21 1,403

   Answers

¹Ì¸£³ª·¡.. 2013/02/09 1,044
3079

 [Notice] 3rd Mission

¹Ì¸£³ª·¡.. 2013/01/20 1,196
3070

 [Notice] Next Book

¹Ì¸£³ª·¡.. 2013/01/15 1,528
3049

 Waves, sound, and Light 2Â÷ ¹Ì¼Ç

[10]
¹Ì¸£³ª·¡.. 2013/01/07 1,710

   Waves, Sound, and Light 2nd Mission Answers

¹Ì¸£³ª·¡.. 2013/01/24 1,088
3047

 Pride and Prejudice 2Â÷ ¹Ì¼Ç

[6]
¹Ì¸£³ª·¡.. 2013/01/07 1,481
3032

 [Notice] 2nd Mission

¹Ì¸£³ª·¡.. 2013/01/02 1,326
3004

 Waves, Sound and light 1Â÷ ¹Ì¼Ç

[9]
¹Ì¸£³ª·¡.. 2012/12/24 2,330